Oscar Ceremony 2015

Contrast is always important but sometimes creates misunderstanding. In any Oscar ceremony, the jury is often selected from a broad spectrum of people who are mostly cinephiles and  their professionalism revolve around film criticism and industry. By contrasting, one can quickly make it clear that the differences can be important as much as the similarities. In the Oscar Ceremony in 2015, the jury concerns recur and can be detected in all of their choices and decisions. Their concerns were related to those 'contrasts' between the nominations that determine the quality of their evaluations and the prosperity of their conceptualizations. Birdman (2014, Alejandro González Iñárritu) and The Grand Budapest Hotel (2014, Wes Anderson) were selected among the group of films which were extraordinary and unique in satisfying the audiences' tastes for audiovisual structures. Both films encompasses the collections of innovative and creative achievements that strengthen the values of Oscar considerations. An Oscar for foreign film Ida(2013, Pawel Pawlikowski) was another surprising moment that astonishes us with the rational and satisfactory result decided by jury. It seems to me that Oscar ceremony tries to catch up with the best film festivals such as Cannes, Venice and Berlin. How Oscar ceremony succeeds to satisfy the professional trained viewers around the world is an unanswerable question, but we should not forget that these kinds of ceremonies integrate the professional of film industries into the pop culture and provide the required launching platform for film artisans and innovators.


By: Morad Sadeghi

Please leave your comments and explain in detail the points and the failures that you find in the texts.

Quattro Mosche di Velluto Grigio (Four Flies on Grey Velvet) (1971, Dario Argento)


Dario Argento giallo genre (mystery, crime) established his reputation throughout his career and helped him to demonstrate an interest in the horror films with psychoanalytic and sexual thematic structures. The nightmarish qualities of his films provide the audience with intellectual support and attitudes the audience arrive at on the screening. I think that Freud and Jung provide Argento a belief system to draw on. Not only is the female protagonist in Four Flies on Grey Velvet schizophernic and sexually abused character, but she represents the dark and mysterious sides of life. Her husband is more stable and sexually healthy. Argento's film narrative seems to suggest that psychoanalytic ideas give him an intellectual credibility to create. The visual style of the film guarantees psychoanalytical reading of the film. The lightings, the point of view shots, the murderous gazes and the dream sequences all reveal the potentiality for psychological deciphering of the film. In the film, the unconscious represents supernatural power and monstrousness of human mind.

Sunshine (2007, Danny Boyle)


Sunshine is the film with all its conventional possibilities of a closed plot in which the scenes tend to give the sense of completeness of the narrative. Somewhat surprisingly, however, the conventional ending of the film is haunting but optimistic. The science fictional and apocalyptic motifs of the film show us how every character achieves quieter maturity towards the end of the narrative. The human sacrificial theme is iterated periodically and the confrontation of scientific and religious stand points reveals the triumph of the scientific endeavor that is impossible without human interference. The symbolic scene of the ending that connects the character's later nightmare to the beauty and the peacefulness of state of his mind at the moment intensifies the necessity of Sun's existence for the survival of humanity. The final moment of the character revelation is coincided with his message that is reviewed by his wife on Earth and is not with any sense of ambiguity and bizarreness. Review By Morad Sadeghi

Les Deux Anglaises et Le Continent(Two English Girls) (1971, François Truffaut)

One of Truffaut's aims in Two English Girls is to underline the differences between English and French cultures in terms of dealing with romantic and sexual subject matters. The tone and the narrative strategy of the film shift when the characters move from British land to French soil and vice versa. The sexual repression scenes and the sexual liberation ones balance each other. Muriels' character(Stacey Tendeter) reveals a certain capacity for traditionalism and morality while Ann's character is more adventurous and risk taker. Ann may be less innocent but more sage. Muriel' s destiny is to suffer. She is the victim of the social tradition that hovers over her romantic and sexual desires. Her loss of virginity at the end of the film is poignant, frightening and violent. If the frame of reference for Muriel 's love  is  19th century romanticism, Ann's love represents a modern 20th century passion for liberation and freedom. The possibilities for the romantic encounters in the love triangle have prompted Truffaut to consider his own love affairs with Catherine Deneuve & Françoise Dorléac as the self-reflexive source for the narrative. Review By Morad Sadeghi

Immigrant (2013, James Gray)

The film already appears to be regarded as a cultural interpretation of the specific era in American history. The lighting and the cinematography of the film are designed to create a perfect tableau of the period. The contradiction between the sense of freedom that American city (New York) represents for the immigrants and the sense of entrapment that the buildings and the tunnels of the city provoke is very important to establish the political connotations of the film. The contrast between the blue colour and the brown colour signify the joyful and the depressive atmospheres of the scenes though the escape scene at the end happens in the environment dominated with blue colour. Marion Cotillard performance is extraordinary and unique. Ewa is naïve but intelligent. Not only is  her immaturity linked to her unfamiliarity with new culture and territory but it is important to shape her character throughout the narrative. There are many shots in the film that owe their effectiveness to her style of performance. We can scarcely anticipate the resolution of the film whose thematic presentation is dominated by the darkness and the depressiveness of the scenes. Of course, Ewa deals with a conflict between love and her familial responsibility. But her role as a wanderer may suffice to demonstrate her attempt to earn a new identity that defines her choice at the end of the film. Review By Morad Sadeghi

1,000 Times Good Night (2013, Erik Poppe) 

Juliet Binoshe performance has the gift of being able to invent a style for the film that draws the particular attention of the critics to its narrative. We can sympathize with her and understand her commitments on both sides, her profession and her family. The crises point arrives when she has to choose between two different sides of her life. The impossibility of reconciliation between these two brings the crisis to its peak. Rebecca tries to heighten her daughter's understanding of political tensions in the world. But there is a sign of optimism in the film when her daughter finally tries to understand her mother in the class assignment by referring to her mom's photographs in Africa. Rebecca's anxiety on the future of the survival of next generations and their political awareness is demonstrated in her role as an observer and journalist at the end of the film. The question of realistic accuracy and precision of photos taken in political turmoil could have been another important aspect of the film that is not structured convincingly. Review By Morad Sadeghi

Kış Uykusu (Winter Sleep)(Nuri Bilge Ceylan, 2014)

 In making Winter Sleep, Ceylan developed his style further and his themes and motives go beyond all  things that have been implied by his best stylistic strategies.The long takes and the shooting on the locations accompanied with the strong characterizations and the well-written dialogues create an astounding and extraordinary cinematic text. Ceylan now with the help of German and French production units succeeds to open a window in front of us in which the class differences become key element to portray the characters. Simultaneously,Aydin's paranoia (Haluk Bilginer) towards his wife and his sense of controlling her life with all of his failures make a platform to launch the narrative. Visually and thematically, he brings all his theatrical experiences into his private life. His house looks like a stage with different rooms and corridors. The house as it is mentioned in a dialogue is like a cave with its claustrophobic and imprisoning structure that works like a shelter for the rich characters to refuge from the harshness of the reality outside(cold and snowy weather). The impossibility of breaking the gap between poor and rich people is intensified with Nihal's failure (Melisa Sozen) to donate Aydin's money as the charity to the poor family.It is so sad that she doesn't have any place to go back except Aydin's house.Not surprisingly, the form and the shape of the location and the narrative is circular with no place to flee. However, Ceylan never attempts to resolve the moral structure of  the narrative.His complete disbelief to offer any solution at the end of the film makes his whole hypothesis about the denial of social classes reconciliation provoking and controversial. We should not forget that there are many cinematic and literary references in the film that is worth to be mentioned such as the hunting scene of the rabbit that reminds us of the hunting scene in Renoir's film, Le Regle du Jeu (The Rules of the Game)(1939) with the similar thematic pattern or Bergmanian and Chekhovian dialogues between the male and the female protagonists. Review By Morad Sadeghi

Don't Look Now (1973, Nicolas Roeg)

Having seen most of this feature I wonder what its complex temporality and eroticism might do to the audiences' power of realization. Perhaps the critics should go further and argue for the purpose of the editing in the film. What I find unforgettable about the film is its multilayered and complicated narrative with supernatural and spiritual themes and motives. By the same token, the title of the film refers to the power of the look and the premonition of its consequences. At the same time, Roeg's stylistic decisions to play with the themes of death and sexuality make the temporal structure of the scenes enigmatic and mysterious. Does this mean that Roeg is capable of charming us with all potential formalistic strategies to change our mindset to the concept of time in his film? Review By Morad Sadeghi